Blog
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.
Can Pets Be Claimed as Dependents? A Real IRS Lawsuit Examined
Many pet owners often find themselves overwhelmed by the financial responsibilities that come with caring for their four-legged family members. If you've ever tallied up your pet's vet bills, grooming costs, daycare fees, and specialty diets and thought, “This is certainly dependent-level care,” you're not alone. This sentiment is now being brought to federal court by one daring New York attorney.
In December 2025, New York legal practitioner Amanda Reynolds initiated litigation against the IRS, seeking recognition for her eight-year-old golden retriever, Finnegan, as a legal dependent under federal tax law.
While this case may seem extraordinary, even surreal, it brings attention to a common query faced by taxpayers: Do any pet-related expenditures qualify as tax-deductible? If not, why is this the case?
Let’s delve into the specifics of this lawsuit, dissect the tax code, and explore the few scenarios where tax benefits for animals might apply.
The Legal Argument: "My Dog Qualifies as a Dependent"
Reynolds asserts in her legal filing that Finnegan satisfies the IRS's dependent criteria because he:
Resides full-time with her,
Lacks independent income, and
Is more than fifty percent financially supported by her, with yearly expenses exceeding $5,000, covering basic necessities and medical care.
A national news report highlights Reynolds's argument, stating, “For all intents and purposes, Finnegan serves the role of a daughter, hence a ‘dependent’ in practical terms.”
In an innovative twist, Reynolds has also introduced constitutional arguments, alleging that the current tax framework discriminates against dependents on "species" grounds, thus violating Equal Protection, and that it constitutes an improper "taking" under the Fifth Amendment.
The Current Status of the Case
Currently, the case is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York and is presently on hold.
A federal magistrate judge has issued a stay of discovery (halting the exchange of evidence) while the IRS prepares to present a motion for dismissal.
The court's written response identifies the lawsuit as proposing a "novel but pressing issue" regarding the assignment of “dependent” status to domestic animals. However, the same decision outlines considerable challenges ahead, noting the federal stance that the claim lacks merit and is likely to fail at the motion-to-dismiss phase.
Why Pets Are Excluded as Dependents in Tax Legislation
The primary obstacle for Reynolds’s case lies in statutory language: dependents are legally defined as “individuals.”
According to the Internal Revenue Code Section 152, a dependent is either a “qualifying child” or a “qualifying relative,” but the term “individual” is historically used to reference human beings.
This is why IRS documentation does not enable listing pets as dependents. Dependents typically possess Social Security numbers or equivalent taxpayer identifiers, and the related tax incentives—credits and deductions—are structured around familial or household relationships between humans.
While Reynolds attempts to argue that Finnegan fulfills the functional dependency test (no income, cohabitation, financial support), the federal tax code does not accommodate animals as dependent “individuals.”
Existing Tax Reliefs for Pet Owners
Despite the general inability to deduct ordinary pet costs, there are notable exceptions where tax benefits could apply—this is where applicable tax advice comes into play.
1) Service Animals as Medical Deductions
Costs related to a trained service animal tasked with aiding disabilities may be considered medical expenses when itemizing deductions.
The IRS outlines that medical expenses may be deductible if they surpass the respective AGI threshold. Within this framework, costs for acquiring, training, and maintaining a service animal—directly linked to medical care—are deemed deductible.
Important Detail: Emotional support animals seldom qualify as service animals under federal regulations; service animals are specifically trained for tasks related to disabilities.
2) Business Animals as Tax-Deductible Expenses
Under certain conditions, animals can play a legitimate role in a trade or business, such as:
Functioning as a guard dog for business security, or
Being used for pest control within a business environment.
In such contexts, various ongoing expenses may be classified as ordinary and necessary business expenses. (Documentation and substantive business purpose are essential.)
The source material identifies this as one of the select areas where animal-related tax advantages are contemplated by the IRS.
3) Charitable Deductions for Foster Animals
Taxpayers fostering animals for eligible organizations may sometimes claim certain unreimbursed expenses as charitable deductions, albeit with stringent criteria and recordkeeping requirements.
Conclusion for Taxpayers
The emotional attachment between people and pets is undeniable; for many, pets are part of the family with evident financial implications. However, tax policies are governed by law, not sentiment, based on precise statutory definitions.
Currently:
You cannot claim pets as dependents on federal tax filings.
Routine pet-related spending (such as general care costs) is typically considered personal and non-deductible.
Certain animal-related expenses may be deductible in specialized situations—service animals, specific business animals, or in select charitable endeavors involving foster care.
As for the Amanda Reynolds case, it offers intriguing prospects, not foretelling a foreseeable change in tax rules regarding dependent IDs for pets, but highlighting the ongoing emotional and financial reliance of many households on their pets, further illustrating the stark contrast in how tax legislation defines “family” versus “property.”
Finally, it's worth noting: always verify with IRS guidelines before assuming an expense is deductible.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.
We care about the protection of your data.
Our Offices
Our expertise is widespread and we have multiple office locations to make it convenient for you to get help. You can find us at:
Smart Tax Financial, LLC - Riverside, CA (Corporate)
Riverside, CA 92505
Phone: (909) 376-8770
FAX: (951) 479-9199
Smart Tax Financial, LLC - Ontario, CA
Ontario, CA 91761
Phone: (909) 376-8770
FAX: (951) 479-9199
Smart Tax Financial, LLC - San Bernardino, CA
San Bernardino, CA 92408
Phone: (909) 376-8770
Fax: (951) 479-9199
Smart Tax Financial, LLC - Riverside, CA (Retail)
Riverside, CA 92505
Phone: (909) 376-8770
Fax: (951) 479-9199